Thursday, November 9

Six mistakes that cost Bilic his West Ham job

Slaven Bilic was a decent man let down by a lack of planning at boardroom level and most managers would have struggled after the stadium move. But he made a number of crucial mistakes too…

PLAYING ANTONIO AT RIGHT BACK
Antonio did a decent job of playing as an emergency right back at the end of the 2015-16 season. But it was always clear that he was one of WHU’s best players as an attacking right winger or striker. It started to go wrong from the first game of the season at Chelsea where Michail conceded a penalty. Yet Bilic seemed obsessed with converting him to right back. He then stockpiled the side with right-wingers he didn’t need like Feghouli and Tore and let Jenkinson return to Arsenal and Moses to Chelsea, leaving us with just the raw Sam Byram at right-back for a season.

SELLING JAMES TOMKINS
The sale of James Tomkins to Crystal Palace in the summer of 2016 was baffling. The fans responded to having a local lad in the team and players like Mark Noble enjoyed having him around too. Bilic said he couldn’t guarantee Tonks first team football, but he would have had been almost permanently in the side as West Ham struggled to find a right back, Ogbonna got injured and lost form and the squad suffered its obligatory injuries. Tomkins wasn’t the best player in the world, but he could play across the back line and always put in a shift. Ultimately Bilic signed the much older Jose Fonte, who for much of his time has looked less impressive than Tomkins.

REPLACING PAYET WITH SNODGRASS
Bilic was badly let-down by Payet, but he replaced him with Robert Snodgrass, a right-sided player who didn’t play in the same position. Snoddy was only given 14 games and then loaned to Aston Villa. The January window is always difficult, so it might have been better to save £10 million and sign a new left-sided midfielder in the summer. Did Bilic even want Snodgrass?

THE SUMMER SIGNINGS OF 2016
Nordtveit, Feghouli, Calleri, Fletcher, Tore, Arbeloa… West Ham needed a couple of world-class players to consolidate after finishing seventh. Instead the summer signings were of quantity rather than quality and it went down as one of the worst windows in West Ham’s history. Maybe some of the signings were Sullivan’s, but Bilic clearly wanted the likes of Tore and Feghouli and he has to take much of the blame.

THAT LOAN DEAL FOR ZAZA
Ironically Simone Zaza is now scoring for fun at Valencia and looks one of the best strikers in Europe have scored nine goals this season in La Liga. The loan deal with a 14-game clause placed too much pressure on Zaza and the club — though this was probably more the board's doing than Slaven's. Had Zaza been successful early on it might even have persuaded Payet to stay all season. Zaza should have either been signed outright or on a season’s loan. And if Bilic really was sure Zaza is world class perhaps West Ham should have gone ahead and signed him at the end of the 14-game spell anyway?

NOT IDENTIFYING A STYLE OF PLAY

Klopp has gegenpressing, Pochettino has pressing and promoting youth, Mourinho has tactical efficiency and a big striker, Wenger has pretty passing patterns, Big Sam plays the percentages and Tony Pulis has a team of massive centre-banks. But we always struggled to know what kind of team Slaven wanted. He wanted to sign pace last summer but ended up with a number of ageing stars and a pedestrian side. With Payet in the side we played flowing football, but since our one world-class player left, the West Ham Way has been unclear.

5 comments:

bubbles said...

Tomkins was sold because he wasn't good enough . He can't even get in Palace team when everyone fit . Payet might well have stayed if there were others around him he could respect and who were on same wave length . What did we have ... NOBLE . Bilic had no plan B and little tactical awareness . His insistence on picking the hapless Captain at the expense of other far more talented players is a mystery . Noble is dragging us into the Championship . He is not a leader and the players only know that he is loyal and will get picked on years service not on ability .We would be better with 10 men than playing this donkey every week . Moyes will get my total support as I love my club but if he picks Noble we will go down . COYI

Pete May said...

Tomkins had four good seasons under Allardyce and did well in Bilic's first season and would have been better than some of our emergency right-backs and stopgap signings. Yes, he's been relatively poor at Palace, but think that's because he didn't really want to leave West Ham. Can't fault Noble's commitment but his legs are fading. He might do a job if surrounded by strong runners but it's looking like he's in his final days.

Anonymous said...

Whatever the deficiencies of particular players in the squad have been or are at the moment, it's become glaringly obvious that a lot of our problems over the last two and a bit seasons have been down to poor fitness and coaching. Comments about a greater intensity in training when players have gone on loan last season are ringing true with what's coming out of the training ground at the moment.You only have to look at kouyate as an example, the man looks like he's been running with deep sea divers boots on for at least a season and a half! I love Bilic the man but he clearly has been far too soft on the senior players, probably expecting them to be grown men and take responsibility and they've taken the P**s.

Pete May said...

Yes, at least Moyes' double training sessions are a step in right direction. Agree about Kouyate who should be a box to box player...

Solution said...

HELLO VIEWERS

TESTIMONY ON HOW I GOT MY LOAN $300,000.00USD FROM A FINANCE COMPANY LAST WEEK Email for immediate response: drbenjaminfinance@gmail.com

Do you need a loan to start a business or pay your debts {Dr.Benjamin Scarlett Owen} can also help you with a legit loan offer. He Has also helped some other colleagues of mine with a loan finance. Get your Blank ATM card or CREDIT CARD deliver to your doorstep that works in all ATM machines all over the world with the help of BENJAMIN LOAN FINANCE the ATM cards can be used to withdraw at the ATM Machines or swipe, at stores and POS. they give out this cards to all interested clients worldwide, If you need a loan without cost/stress he his the right loan lender to wipe away your financial problems and crisis today. BENJAMIN LOAN FINANCE holds all of the information about how to obtain money quickly and painlessly via Email drbenjaminfinance@gmail.com

THANK YOU ALL